[Asrg] DNSBL BCP - enough, already, of the amateur lawyering

Chris Lewis clewis at nortel.com
Wed Apr 2 09:44:17 PDT 2008


John Levine wrote:

> So I think we MUST take out anythink that's likely to be read as legal
> advice.
> 
> On the other hand, if this BCP is successful, we can expect people to
> wave it around in court cases to try to establish that some blacklist
> does or does not act in accordance with industry standards.  So please
> concentrate on making it clear, and keeping in mind the C, not too far
> from what respectable BLs do now.

Try this rewrite (gets rid of a legal note)

<t>A DNSBL without DNSBL users does not
block (or otherwise impair) email or any other Internet service.
A DNSBL user voluntarily uses the DNSBL data to guide their decisions,
and the user therefore MUST assume responsibility for the
consequences.</t>

<t>DNSBL operators are expressing an opinion through the
publication of a DNSBL.  However,
it is through abiding by the guidelines set forth in this BCP that
the operators of a DNSBL may gain the trust of their users.</t>


More information about the Asrg mailing list