[rrg] Smart host, dumb network - core-edge-sep. doesn't alter this

Robin Whittle rw at firstpr.com.au
Tue Nov 18 00:55:03 PST 2008


Short version:   A core-edge separation scheme is more in keeping
                 with the Internet tradition - where the host is not
                 concerned with moment-to-moment connectivity changes
                 in the network - than a host-based system which
                 copes with this stuff so the existing routing system
                 can remain simple and unchanged.

                 There seems to be a steep set of barriers to making
                 all the changes required to get everyone to
                 transition to a new Internet with new host stack
                 capabilities and all applications rewritten to use a
                 purely host-name interface to the stack.

Hi Tony,

You wrote:

> If we want to change the architecture to something that we can live with in
> perpetuity, we might want to step back and take a larger view of the world.
> IPv6 is coming, like it or not.  If its routing architecture is
> fundamentally flawed and we have to deploy awkward systems to compensate,
> then we will have to live with those indefinitely.



More information about the rrg mailing list